Book review of "You Can Write Your Family History" by Sharon DeBartolo Carmack
Review written by Larisa S. Asaeli
Paperback: 256 pages; Online Price: $17.95 on Amazon
This book is a friendly and encouraging
guide for writing a family history. Ms. Carmack takes a daunting task and
breaks it down into well-defined and manageable steps that will allow even the busiest of us to make the needed headway on that family history we
have been meaning to write (or finish writing).
The most important lesson Carmack teaches is that everyone can be a writer
and "practically everyone has the potential to write a family history" (p.
1). With that encouragement, she gives some very basic and helpful steps,
and recommends taking the project one step at a time. The reader can easily do this by following her "ten
characteristics of a quality family history"--a basic recipe for the family
history (p. 5). With this recipe in mind, she coaches readers through each
step in an encouraging voice that makes one feel as if the task will come
out great.
The first step, is to determine the genre, or type of history, you will
write. Carmack includes a helpful table that defines and discusses the
different genres and includes examples and further references. Some well-known examples she refers to are Frank McCourt's Angela's Ashes and
Alex Haley's Roots. Carmack points out that while we don't have to
emulate such literary greatness, it is helpful to know some examples and
styles one can follow.
Next, in Step 2, she discusses the scope of the project and invites writers to define
"what you will include and what you will leave for another book" (p. 13).
The first step towards deciding this is to determine who your audience is. This is an important
basic step in writing. If you are writing for your family only, you can
infer some understood references or allusions. But, as Carmack points out,
other researchers may use your history, so it is important that you document
your sources clearly. This way others do not have to go back and redo any
research.
The most important point in determining your project's scope is to decide
how many family lines or branches of the family tree you will include in
your history. Carmack gives some helpful organization plans based on the number of family lines you want to include in your history, which can be paternal, maternal, or both.
Step 3 is determining when you have finished researching and have enough
information to begin writing your history. In this chapter Carmack discusses
the value of detailed and well documented family group records and family
summaries as a basis for the family history.
The next chapter, Step 4, "Determining the Plot and Structure," is the most
helpful out of all the book's chapters. In this step Carmack isolates and
gives recipes for structuring your family story. She suggests looking for
"family and personal struggles" around which to base your narrative. She also
identifies "some common family history plots": Immigration, Pioneer Saga, Rags to Riches, Rising Out of Slavery, War and Military Survival, and
City Dweller to Country Dweller (p. 29-31). Once you have identified the
plot you will use, she gives some basic formulas to follow for narrating the
time of the story and provides some specific examples. And while Carmack
claims she never uses the outlines she was taught by her English teachers,
she does encourage planning the narrative in whatever format works best for
you as a writer, especially if you are writing what she calls the "All-My-Ancestors Book" (p. 39-40).
Step 5, "Isolating Themes in Your Family History," piggybacks with step 4.
The themes are what makes the story come alive, especially if you are
writing about ancestors that are "boring." Carmack lists some themes to
consider when writing the history, such as education, food, religion,
reproductive cycles, and leisure. These themes also may be sensitive in
nature, so she urges writers to be cautious when approaching topics such as
alcoholism, children born out of wedlock, or domestic abuse. She does not
believe in covering up details or hiding family secrets, but urges writers
to "simply report on the facts of [your ancestors'] lives, whether we agree
with their decisions or not" (p. 56).
The next step in fleshing out your narrative is to find background
information about the localities in which your ancestors lived. In the 7th
chapter, Carmack discusses different types of sources that provide
information about those locations. She provides helpful examples from her
own writing that make this step seem easily accomplished. After finding this
information, Carmack suggest looking at social histories so that you can set
your family in their historical context and make their stories come alive.
One suggestion that was new to me, was to look at cookbooks for clues about
what your ancestors might have eaten (p. 78). Such details would help with
an immigration narrative. Finally, Carmack says that with all this planning
completed and material gathered, you are ready to begin writing.
The next sections of the book focus on the nitty-gritty of the writing,
such as style, focusing your story, transitions, point of view, and
narrative voice. While all of these skills of writing are taught in basic
writing classes, Carmack's explanations here will help those whose skills
are a bit rusty. Steps 10 and 11 focus on developing details about
characters and setting. For instance, Carmack suggests commenting on
photographs that are included with your story to "point out details your
readers might not have noticed" (p. 113), such as the style of clothing or
the absence of jewelery on your ancestor. She also encourages the use of
sensory details since readers may want "to experience what life was like in
your ancestors' days" (p. 123). All such details, she asserts, will help
draw readers into your text.
Step 12 deals with the incorporation of oral family tales into the
narrative. She points out how to find people to interview, cite the source,
and format dialogue. Steps 13 and 14 are about polishing off your writing to
keep your readers interested. She suggests possibly including suspense,
humor, and romance (along with historical events), into the narrative to
really bring your ancestor's story to life.
The last five steps deal with finishing the narrative off with
documentation, illustrations, and an index, as well as information about
publishing and marketing your book. These sections are most helpful for the
novice writer since there is no standardized citation format for writing a
family history. Carmack discusses different methods and gives examples of
her preferred formats. She also includes sample illustrations and photos and
discusses how to use them in your narrative. The differences between self-publication, print on demand, and marketing your book are also presented.
Lastly, a strength of this book is its helpful appendices. This includes a bibliography with further sources to help you with your research and
writing; two sample excerpts of family histories; a list of writing courses,
contests, organizations, and conferences; and an index of key ideas and
names in the book.
Overall, this is a fine book about writing a family history. The format of
the text allows readers to get a quick sense of the task and its steps so
that writers can begin writing immediately. There are ample supplementary
materials referenced and the examples provided will make this task much more
manageable for busy genealogists and family historians.
Article written by Larisa S. Asaeli